The ParaGard intrauterine device (IUD) has become the center of significant legal controversy, with thousands of women across the United States joining a mass litigation against its manufacturers. As of early 2025, the ParaGard multidistrict litigation (MDL) has grown to include over 2,690 cases, making it one of the most significant women’s health legal battles in recent years.
What Is ParaGard and Why Is It Under Legal Scrutiny?
ParaGard is a T-shaped copper intrauterine device that provides hormone-free birth control for up to 10 years. Unlike hormonal IUDs, ParaGard uses copper’s natural spermicidal properties to prevent pregnancy. This has made it a popular choice for women seeking long-term contraception without hormonal side effects, capturing approximately 17% of the U.S. IUD market as of 2024.
However, the device has come under intense legal scrutiny due to reports of serious complications, particularly during removal. The primary allegation in the ParaGard lawsuits is that the device is prone to breaking during the removal process, with the arms of the T-shaped device becoming brittle and breaking off inside the uterus. This can lead to a range of serious health complications that may require additional surgeries and potentially cause long-term health issues.
Key Allegations in the ParaGard Lawsuits
Plaintiffs in the ParaGard litigation are making several key allegations against manufacturers Teva Pharmaceuticals (the original manufacturer) and CooperSurgical (which acquired ParaGard in 2017):
- Design Defect: The lawsuits claim that ParaGard IUDs have an inherent design flaw that makes them prone to fracturing during removal, even when healthcare providers follow proper removal procedures.
- Failure to Warn: Plaintiffs allege that the manufacturers failed to adequately warn both patients and healthcare providers about the risk of device breakage and potential complications.
- Negligence: The manufacturers are accused of negligence in the design, testing, manufacturing, and marketing of the ParaGard IUD.
Reported Complications and Health Injuries
Women who have filed lawsuits report a wide range of complications following the breakage of their ParaGard IUD, including:
- Severe pain and heavy bleeding
- Perforation of the uterus
- Migration of device fragments to other organs
- Infections and Pelvic Inflammatory Disease (PID)
- Organ damage
- Infertility issues
- Need for additional invasive procedures such as hysteroscopy, laparoscopy, or in severe cases, hysterectomy
These complications not only cause physical suffering but can also lead to significant emotional distress, lost wages, and substantial medical expenses.
Understanding the ParaGard MDL: Not a Traditional Class Action
It’s important to clarify that despite being commonly referred to as a “class action,” the ParaGard litigation is technically a multidistrict litigation (MDL). This distinction matters for affected individuals:
MDL vs. Class Action: What’s the Difference?
- In an MDL: Each plaintiff maintains their individual lawsuit and seeks damages based on their specific injuries and circumstances. The cases are consolidated only for pre-trial proceedings to improve efficiency.
- In a class action: A single lawsuit is filed on behalf of a group of similarly affected people, and any settlement is typically divided equally among class members.
The ParaGard cases have been consolidated into MDL 2974 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, under Judge Leigh Martin May. This consolidation helps streamline the pre-trial process, avoid duplicative discovery, and promote consistent rulings across all cases.
Current Status of the ParaGard Litigation (2025)
As of April 2025, the ParaGard MDL includes over 2,690 individual lawsuits. The litigation is progressing through the pre-trial phase, with the first bellwether trials scheduled for early 2025. These bellwether trials will serve as test cases to help both sides gauge how juries are likely to respond to the evidence and arguments presented.
The outcomes of these initial trials will significantly influence settlement negotiations, as they provide insight into potential jury awards and help establish the overall value of the claims.
Scientific Evidence Supporting the Claims
Several scientific studies and reports have raised concerns about the safety of ParaGard IUDs:
- A 2022 study published in the journal Contraception found that copper IUDs like ParaGard had higher breakage rates than hormonal IUDs.
- The FDA has received thousands of adverse event reports related to ParaGard, documenting instances of device breakage, migration, and uterine perforation.
This scientific evidence is crucial to the plaintiffs’ cases, as it helps establish a causal link between the design of the ParaGard IUD and the injuries reported by women.
Potential Settlement Amounts for Plaintiffs
While it’s still premature to determine exact settlement amounts in the ParaGard litigation, legal experts have suggested potential compensation tiers based on similar mass tort cases involving defective medical devices:
Estimated Settlement Tiers
- Tier I (Most Severe Injuries): $100,000 – $380,000
Examples: Infertility, severe infections requiring extensive treatment, permanent organ damage - Tier II (Moderate Injuries): $40,000 – $75,000
Examples: Injuries requiring multiple surgical procedures, significant but non-permanent health issues - Tier III (Less Severe Injuries): $10,000 – $30,000
Examples: Pain and discomfort without permanent injury, minor procedures required
These figures remain speculative and will ultimately depend on several factors, including:
- The strength of scientific evidence linking ParaGard to the alleged injuries
- The outcomes of the bellwether trials
- The defendants’ financial considerations and litigation strategy
- Individual case specifics, including severity of injuries and medical documentation
Why ParaGard Remains on the Market Despite Lawsuits
Despite the mounting legal challenges and numerous reported adverse events, ParaGard remains available on the market. The FDA has not issued a recall for ParaGard related to breakage issues. This has raised concerns among patient advocacy groups about the regulatory process for medical devices and the standard of evidence required to trigger a safety recall.
The lack of a recall does not, however, diminish the legal claims of women who have experienced complications. Courts evaluate product liability claims based on different standards than those used by regulatory agencies.
What To Do If You’ve Been Injured by a ParaGard IUD
If you suspect you’ve experienced complications related to a ParaGard IUD, it’s crucial to take the following steps:
1. Seek Immediate Medical Attention
Your health should be your primary concern. Consult with your healthcare provider if you experience symptoms such as:
- Severe abdominal pain
- Heavy or unusual bleeding
- Fever or signs of infection
- Pain during intercourse
- Unusual discharge
Proper medical documentation of your condition is also essential for any potential legal claim.
2. Preserve Evidence
Request and maintain copies of:
- All medical records related to your ParaGard IUD insertion and removal
- Documentation of any complications or additional procedures
- Proof of ParaGard IUD implantation (product information, lot numbers if available)
- Photographs of the removed device (if possible)
3. Consult with an Experienced Attorney
Contact a qualified attorney who specializes in medical device litigation. Most attorneys handling ParaGard cases offer free consultations and work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you don’t pay unless they secure compensation for you. At AllConsumer.com, we can connect you with resources to get you started.
An experienced attorney can:
- Evaluate your eligibility to join the MDL
- Gather necessary evidence to support your claim
- Navigate the complex legal process on your behalf
- Represent your interests in settlement negotiations or at trial
4. Be Mindful of Time Limitations
Every state has statutes of limitations that restrict the time period during which you can file a lawsuit. These deadlines vary by state but typically range from 1-6 years from the date of injury or discovery of injury. Consulting with an attorney promptly ensures you don’t lose your right to seek compensation.
The Importance of Legal Representation in Mass Tort Cases
Navigating the ParaGard MDL requires specialized legal knowledge and experience. The defendants—Teva Pharmaceuticals and CooperSurgical—are large corporations with substantial resources and experienced legal teams. Individual plaintiffs benefit significantly from having skilled legal representation to level the playing field.
An attorney who specializes in medical device litigation can:
- Accurately value your claim based on precedent and specific circumstances
- Handle complex legal procedures and documentation requirements
- Counter defense strategies effectively
- Work with medical experts to establish causation
- Ensure your voice is heard in the litigation process
Looking Forward
As the first bellwether trials approach, both plaintiffs and defendants are preparing their strategies. The outcomes of these initial trials will likely set the tone for how the remainder of the litigation proceeds.
Several possible scenarios may unfold:
- Settlement Before Trials: The defendants might opt to settle cases before the bellwether trials begin if they believe the evidence against them is strong.
- Post-Bellwether Global Settlement: If the initial trials result in plaintiff victories with significant damage awards, the defendants may pursue a global settlement to resolve all remaining cases.
- Continued Litigation: If the defendants prevail in the bellwether trials or believe the awarded damages are manageable, they might choose to continue fighting the claims.
- Mixed Results Leading to Negotiation: Mixed outcomes in the bellwether trials could lead to nuanced settlement negotiations based on case strengths and weaknesses.
Staying Informed About the ParaGard Class Action
The ParaGard litigation represents a significant case in the ongoing effort to hold medical device manufacturers accountable for product safety. As the legal proceedings continue to evolve throughout 2025 and beyond, affected women should stay informed about developments that could impact their rights and potential compensation.
If you believe you’ve been injured by a ParaGard IUD, remember that you’re not alone. Thousands of women across the country have reported similar experiences and are seeking justice through the legal system. By understanding your rights and options, you can make informed decisions about how to proceed.
For those considering birth control options, this litigation also serves as a reminder of the importance of discussing all potential risks with healthcare providers and making fully informed decisions about reproductive health.
At AllConsumer.com, we advocate for your right to safety and open information. Sign up today for up-to-date information on the products you’re consuming.
